My father, Gerald Raymond Kowalski, died of prostate cancer at seventy-eight in the house on Copley Road in Akron, Ohio where he had lived for forty years, in the bedroom that faced the backyard maple tree he had planted the spring I was born.
I am fifty-one. My name is Steven. My brother Dale is forty-eight and lives in Cleveland and had driven to Akron three days before our father died to be there, which meant that when the end came it came with both of us present and our mother, Evelyn, who had been married to Gerald for forty-seven years and who held his hand at the last moment with the specific composure of a woman who has loved someone for most of her life and has been preparing for this without allowing herself to prepare.
My father was, in every observable way, an uncomplicated man. He had worked as a licensed electrician for thirty-one years. He fished the Cuyahoga River on Saturday mornings from April through October. He watched Cleveland Browns games with a loyalty that was not discouraged by the outcomes. He coached youth soccer for eight years when Dale and I were growing up. He fixed things that broke — in our house, in the neighbors’ houses, in whatever came to his attention — with the methodical competence of a man who found satisfaction in function and disorder in dysfunction.
He asked for very little. He gave consistently. He occupied his corner of the world with the steady, unremarkable decency that I understand now, at fifty-one, is not unremarkable at all but is in fact one of the more difficult things a person can maintain for an entire lifetime.
In the final week, the medication he was on produced variable effects — some hours he was unclear, present in a room that existed only for him, speaking to people who weren’t there. Other hours he was more lucid than he had been in months, the way people sometimes are near the end, as if the proximity of it burns away everything nonessential and leaves something very clear.
It was during one of the clear hours that he asked my mother and Dale to give us a moment.
My mother looked at him.
He held her gaze.
She nodded and took Dale out.
My father took my hand.
He spoke for approximately six minutes.
Eleven sentences. I counted them later, writing them down from memory because I needed them to exist outside my head.
In 1974 he was twenty-six years old, not yet met my mother, working a job in Pittsburgh that had lasted eight months. He had a relationship with a woman named Carol Brennan. The relationship ended when the job ended and he came back to Akron. Three months after he returned, Carol called him.
She was pregnant.
They had several conversations. Carol did not want to move to Akron. My father did not want to move to Pittsburgh. Carol did not want an abortion. My father sent money — monthly, for years, through an arrangement that was informal but consistent, ceasing when Carol wrote to tell him the child was established and he was released from the obligation.
The child was a girl. Carol named her Patricia.
She would be, my father said, forty-nine years old.
He had never met her. He had thought about her every year. He did not know if she knew about him.
He asked me to find her if I could. He said he didn’t deserve to ask it but was asking anyway.
He died on a Thursday morning four days later, with my mother and Dale and me in the room, in the early light coming through the window onto the maple tree he had planted the spring I was born.
I told my mother that evening. She sat with it for a long time. Then she said: “He was a good man who did an imperfect thing. Find her if she wants to be found.”
I spent six months looking.
I found Carol Brennan through public records — she was seventy-three, still in Pittsburgh, and when I wrote to her she replied after two weeks with a letter that was careful and not unkind. She told me that Patricia knew. That Patricia had known for several years, having done a DNA ancestry test that had returned results she had then researched. That Patricia had been deciding for some time whether to reach out.
Carol gave me no contact information for Patricia. She said that was Patricia’s to give or not give as she chose.
I understood.
Six weeks after Carol’s letter, on a Tuesday evening in November, I heard a knock at my front door.
I was in the kitchen making dinner. My wife Sandra called from the living room that someone was at the door. I went.
I opened the door.
A woman stood on my porch. Perhaps fifty. Brown coat. Brown hair going gray at the temples. A face that was arranged into the careful composure of someone who had rehearsed this moment many times and was now arriving at it and finding that rehearsal had prepared her incompletely.
I looked at her face.
I could not speak.
Not from shock exactly — I had been expecting something, had been waiting for something. But expecting a thing and encountering it are different experiences, and what I encountered on my porch was my father’s face on a fifty-year-old woman I had never met.
His jaw. His eyes — the particular dark brown with the slight downward tilt at the corners. The way she held her head when she was uncertain, slightly forward, which was exactly how he had held his.
She looked at me.
I think she saw the same thing.
“I’m Patricia,” she said. Her voice was steady. She had worked for that steadiness.
“I know,” I said.
We stood there for a moment.
Then I opened the door wider.
“Come in,” I said. “I’ve been looking for you.”
She came in.
Sandra appeared from the living room, took in the situation with the intelligence she has always had for understanding things quickly, and went to the kitchen to make tea without being asked.
Patricia and I sat in the living room and talked for four hours.
She told me about her life — Pittsburgh, a career in nursing, a marriage of twenty years, two children who were now in college. She told me about the DNA test and the research and the long period of deciding.
I told her about our father. Everything I could remember, as much detail as I could provide, because it was the only thing I had to give her that she didn’t already have.
At midnight she said she needed to get back to her hotel.
At the door she turned.
“He sent money,” she said. “My mother told me. Until I was twelve.”
“He told me,” I said.
She nodded.
“I don’t know what to do with that,” she said. “I don’t know if it makes it better or worse.”
“I don’t either,” I said.
She looked at me for a moment — my father’s eyes in her face, looking at my face that also had our father’s eyes.
“I’ll call you,” she said.
She has.